Showing posts with label Shimon Peres. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shimon Peres. Show all posts

Thursday, November 24, 2016

The Olsa Academic Fantasy Disaster





Prof. Efraim Karsh, the incoming director of the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, indicts the Oslo diplomatic process as “the starkest strategic blunder in Israel’s history” and as “one of the worst calamities ever to have afflicted Israelis and Palestinians.”

“Twenty three years after its euphoric launch on the White House lawn,” Karsh writes in this comprehensive study, “the Oslo ‘peace process’ has substantially worsened the position of both parties and made the prospects for peace and reconciliation ever more remote.”

“The process has led to establishment of an ineradicable terror entity on Israel’s doorstep, deepened Israel’s internal cleavages, destabilized its political system, and weakened its international standing.”

“It has been a disaster for West Bank and Gaza Palestinians too. It has brought about subjugation to corrupt and repressive PLO and Hamas regimes. These regimes have reversed the hesitant advent of civil society in these territories, shattered their socioeconomic wellbeing, and made the prospects for peace and reconciliation with Israel ever more remote.”

“This abject failure is a direct result of the Palestinian leadership’s perception of the process as a pathway not to a two-state solution – meaning Israel alongside a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza – but to the subversion of the State of Israel. They view Oslo not as a path to nation-building and state creation, but to the formation of a repressive terror entity that perpetuates conflict with Israel, while keeping its hapless constituents in constant and bewildered awe as Palestinian leaders line their pockets from the proceeds of this misery.”

Karsh details at length how the Oslo process has weakened Israel’s national security in several key respects.

On the strategic and military levels, it allowed the PLO to achieve in one fell swoop its strategic vision of transforming the West Bank and the Gaza Strip into terror hotbeds that would disrupt Israel’s way of life (to use Yasser Arafat’s words).

Politically and diplomatically, he says, Oslo instantaneously transformed the PLO (and, to a lesser extent, Hamas) into an internationally accepted political actor while upholding its commitment to Israel’s destruction, edging toward fully fledged statehood outside the Oslo framework, and steadily undermining Israel’s international standing.

The ending of Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian population of the territories within three-and-a-half years from the onset of the process has gone totally unnoticed (due partly to Palestinian propaganda, partly to Israel’s failure to get this critical point across), with the Jewish state still subject to international opprobrium for the nonexistent “occupation.”

Domestically, Oslo radicalized Israel’s Arab minority, nipping in the bud its decades-long “Israelization” process and putting it on a collision course with Israel’s Jewish community. No less importantly, it made Israeli politics captive to the vicissitudes of Palestinian-Israeli relations, with the PLO and Hamas becoming the effective arbiters of Israel’s political discourse and electoral process.

“On the face of it,” Karsh writes, “Israel’s massive setbacks can be considered Palestinian gains. Yet one’s loss is not necessarily the other’s gain. The Palestinian leadership’s zero-sum approach and predication of Palestinian national identity on hatred of the ‘other,’ rather than on a distinct shared legacy, has resulted in decades of dispersal and statelessness.”

“Even if the PLO were to succeed in gaining international recognition of a fully fledged Palestinian state (with or without a formal peace treaty with Israel) and in preventing Hamas from seizing power, it would still be a failed entity in the worst tradition of Arab dictatorships, in permanent conflict with its Israeli neighbor while brutally repressing its unfortunate subjects.”

Karsh bemoans that fact that “there has been no real reckoning by the Oslo architects and their erstwhile ‘peace camp’ successors, both in Israel and abroad, of the worst blunder in Israel’s history, and no rethinking of its disastrously misconceived assumptions – let alone any public admission of guilt or show of remorse over its horrific costs.”

“Instead, they continue to willfully ignore the Palestinian leadership’s total lack of interest in the two-state solution and serial violation of contractual obligations. They continue to whitewash ongoing Palestinian violence, belittle the extent of Israeli suffering, and blame Jerusalem for the stalled process despite the public endorsement of the two-state solution by five successive Israeli prime ministers: Peres, Barak, Sharon, Olmert, and Netanyahu.”

“Not only has the same terror-tainted Palestinian leadership come to be universally viewed as the prospective government of a future Palestinian state, but its goal of having this state established without negotiating with Israel, or even recognizing its right to exist, seems to be gaining ever wider currency. This soft racism – asking nothing of the Palestinians as if they are too dim or too primitive to be held accountable for their own words and actions – is an assured recipe for disaster.”

“For so long as not a single Palestinian leader evinces genuine acceptance of the two-state solution or acts in a way signifying an unqualified embrace of the idea, there can be no true or lasting reconciliation with Israel. And so long as the territories continue to be governed by the PLO’s and Hamas’s rule of the jungle, no Palestinian civil society, let alone a viable state, can develop.”

“Just as the creation of free and democratic societies in Germany and Japan after World War II necessitated a comprehensive sociopolitical and educational transformation, so it will only be when Palestinian society undergoes a real ‘spring’ that the century-long conflict between Arabs and Jews can at long last be resolved and a semi-functioning Palestinian state come into being. This requires sweeping the corrupt and oppressive PLO and Hamas rulers from power, eliminating endemic violence from political and social life, and teaching the virtues of coexistence with Israeli neighbors.”

“Sadly, the possibility of a Palestinian spring, which seemed to be in the offing in 1993 when the PLO hovered on the verge of extinction and West Bank and Gaza leadership appeared eager to strike a historic deal within the framework of the Washington peace negotiations, has been destroyed for the foreseeable future by the Oslo ‘peace process’.”

A renowned authority on Middle Eastern history and politics, Prof. Karsh has authored over 100 scholarly articles and sixteen books, and is editor of the Middle East Quarterly and Israel Affairs academic journals.

Prof. Efraim Karsh taught for 25 years at King’s College London, where he founded and directed the Middle East and Mediterranean Studies Program (currently the Institute of Middle Eastern Studies). In 2013 he joined Bar-Ilan University as professor of political science. In November 2016 he will succeed Prof. Efraim Inbar as director of the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies.

Sunday, October 2, 2016

Obama's uncomplicated appreciation of Peres

Image result for shimon peres obama medal of freedom

When a great man dies his loss is felt. This is particularly true in the case of Shimon Peres, who was active until his very last days. The tremendous outpouring of emotion from around the world is just one indication of the profound mark Peres made during his lifetime.

Dozens of statesmen are expected to attend the funeral, which is slated to be the largest gathering of world leaders in Israel since the funeral of Yitzhak Rabin in 1995. But of all the statesmen who will be in Jerusalem to pay tribute to Peres, one stands out: US President Barack Obama.

That the leader of the most powerful nation in the world found the time to make the long trip to Israel as a personal gesture of honor to Peres should not be taken for granted.

The US president went out of his way both literally and figuratively to pay his respects to Israel’s former president and prime minister and by extension to Israel.

In an unusually long and personal statement, Obama described their first meeting, while he was a United States senator, and he described their conversations in detail.

“Shimon was the essence of Israel itself,” he said.

“A light has gone out, but the hope he gave us will burn forever,” he said. “Shimon Peres was a soldier for Israel, for the Jewish people, for justice, for peace and for the belief that we can be true to our best selves – to the very end of our time on earth and in the legacy that we leave to others.” 

Obama added that Peres had changed the course of history by expanding the “moral imagination” and forcing people to expect more from themselves.

In a rare act of respect, Obama ordered all US flags on federal property to be flown at half-staff through sunset Friday in memory of Peres.

Obama’s order covers all federal buildings and grounds throughout the United States and its territories, as well as embassies, military bases and other facilities abroad.

Obama’s extraordinary statements and acts of respect toward Peres can be attributed in part to the US president’s affinity for Israel and the Jews. From the beginning of his political career, Obama has received the support of America’s Jewish community – particularly the liberal-minded among them – first in Chicago and later nationwide.

Obama’s expansive statements on Peres and the speed with which he announced his intention to attend Peres’s funeral reflect more than his affinity for Israel. Obama personally identifies with Peres and sees in him a role model and a man who represents Israel’s best qualities. He was the face of Israel that Obama – and many others – want to see: a committed optimist who was convinced the forces of technology and human progress are unabashedly positive and ultimately unstoppable. This led him and many other Israelis to believe that peace was attainable.

Obama also knew that Peres believed him when he said America has Israel’s back whether on the Palestinian front or on the issue of Iran’s nuclear weapons program.

Though his critics accused him of being naive and disconnected from reality, Peres is so widely admired because he refused to remain a pragmatic, realistic politician. He was a true leader who, in the words of Obama, “expanded our moral imagination.” He urged us all to go beyond the here and now to a brighter future.

Obama is likely to use the occasion of the funeral to encourage Israel to fulfill Peres’s legacy by renewing attempts at dialogue with the Palestinians.

“I can think of no greater tribute to his life than to renew our commitment to the peace that we know is possible,” Obama said.

We hope that Obama will stand by the principle which Peres supported, namely that any peace agreement reached between Israel and the Palestinians must be the result of dialogue and mutual compromise. Unilateral moves – such as a UN Security Council resolution – are counterproductive and will not lead to the peace that Peres and those he inspired knew was attainable.

Though Obama clashed frequently with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the issues of settlements and the Iran nuclear deal, ties between the countries have remained strong.

On Obama’s watch there was unprecedented military cooperation between the US and Israel, which climaxed with the signing of the 10-year, $38 billion military aid package earlier this month. Obama’s arrival to bid farewell to one of Israel’s founding fathers is another expression of that relationship, one that we should appreciate.

Obama's uncomplicated appreciation of Peres

Image result for shimon peres obama medal of freedom

When a great man dies his loss is felt. This is particularly true in the case of Shimon Peres, who was active until his very last days. The tremendous outpouring of emotion from around the world is just one indication of the profound mark Peres made during his lifetime.

Dozens of statesmen are expected to attend the funeral, which is slated to be the largest gathering of world leaders in Israel since the funeral of Yitzhak Rabin in 1995. But of all the statesmen who will be in Jerusalem to pay tribute to Peres, one stands out: US President Barack Obama.

That the leader of the most powerful nation in the world found the time to make the long trip to Israel as a personal gesture of honor to Peres should not be taken for granted.

The US president went out of his way both literally and figuratively to pay his respects to Israel’s former president and prime minister and by extension to Israel.

In an unusually long and personal statement, Obama described their first meeting, while he was a United States senator, and he described their conversations in detail.

“Shimon was the essence of Israel itself,” he said.

“A light has gone out, but the hope he gave us will burn forever,” he said. “Shimon Peres was a soldier for Israel, for the Jewish people, for justice, for peace and for the belief that we can be true to our best selves – to the very end of our time on earth and in the legacy that we leave to others.” 

Obama added that Peres had changed the course of history by expanding the “moral imagination” and forcing people to expect more from themselves.

In a rare act of respect, Obama ordered all US flags on federal property to be flown at half-staff through sunset Friday in memory of Peres.

Obama’s order covers all federal buildings and grounds throughout the United States and its territories, as well as embassies, military bases and other facilities abroad.

Obama’s extraordinary statements and acts of respect toward Peres can be attributed in part to the US president’s affinity for Israel and the Jews. From the beginning of his political career, Obama has received the support of America’s Jewish community – particularly the liberal-minded among them – first in Chicago and later nationwide.

Obama’s expansive statements on Peres and the speed with which he announced his intention to attend Peres’s funeral reflect more than his affinity for Israel. Obama personally identifies with Peres and sees in him a role model and a man who represents Israel’s best qualities. He was the face of Israel that Obama – and many others – want to see: a committed optimist who was convinced the forces of technology and human progress are unabashedly positive and ultimately unstoppable. This led him and many other Israelis to believe that peace was attainable.

Obama also knew that Peres believed him when he said America has Israel’s back whether on the Palestinian front or on the issue of Iran’s nuclear weapons program.

Though his critics accused him of being naive and disconnected from reality, Peres is so widely admired because he refused to remain a pragmatic, realistic politician. He was a true leader who, in the words of Obama, “expanded our moral imagination.” He urged us all to go beyond the here and now to a brighter future.

Obama is likely to use the occasion of the funeral to encourage Israel to fulfill Peres’s legacy by renewing attempts at dialogue with the Palestinians.

“I can think of no greater tribute to his life than to renew our commitment to the peace that we know is possible,” Obama said.

We hope that Obama will stand by the principle which Peres supported, namely that any peace agreement reached between Israel and the Palestinians must be the result of dialogue and mutual compromise. Unilateral moves – such as a UN Security Council resolution – are counterproductive and will not lead to the peace that Peres and those he inspired knew was attainable.

Though Obama clashed frequently with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the issues of settlements and the Iran nuclear deal, ties between the countries have remained strong.

On Obama’s watch there was unprecedented military cooperation between the US and Israel, which climaxed with the signing of the 10-year, $38 billion military aid package earlier this month. Obama’s arrival to bid farewell to one of Israel’s founding fathers is another expression of that relationship, one that we should appreciate.