Showing posts with label Syria. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Syria. Show all posts

Sunday, February 5, 2017

Time to Make Decisions in the Middle East and Zion, #OyVeyDonald Trump, Strategic Balance, Palestinian -Israeli Conflict, Intervention in Syria,New Security Doctrine, IDF Bashing and Morality Challanges


Related image


The Institute for National Security Studies (INSS) recently held its annual conference, which was attended by statesmen, military commanders, media figures, and political and security experts from Israel and abroad. As true of any conference of this type, many divergent opinions were expressed on a range of topics. They sketched a complex picture of Israel’s current situation and the challenges it can expect to face in 2017. Based on the mosaic of opinions presented at the conference, several distinct, unambiguous trends characterizing this moment in time did emerge from the event.

Strategic Balance

Israel’s overall strategic balance is positive. Israel is viewed as a regional power with undeniable military superiority over its rivals and enemies. Its regional situation is stable, mostly due to the weakening of its rivals by many years of internal wars in the Arab world. The ongoing bloodbaths in Syria, Iraq, Libya, and Yemen are not expected to end any time soon. The power struggle for regional hegemony between Iran, Turkey, and the Sunni states led by Saudi Arabia is a destabilizing factor and leaves little hope for sustainable mitigation of the region’s religious, ethnic, and national enmity. Nonetheless, in the internal and international arenas, Israel’s situation is deteriorating, a fact upon which we focus below.

Ramifications of Donald Trump’s Presidency
Trump’s presidency was the major change affecting the conference, coloring virtually every discussion, including those debating the risks, but even more so when “Trumpportunities” were identified, especially from the perspective of Russia and right-wing parties in Israel.

The dramatic shifts in the West, primarily Trump’s election to the US presidency and the United Kingdom’s decision—based on a popular referendum—to withdraw from the European Union (Brexit), have shaken up the international community’s agenda. These shifts are a direct consequence of deep subterranean processes that have taken place over the last decade. They reflect an isolationist desire on the part of western societies and are manifested by the rise of the nationalistic right at an unprecedented scope since the end of World War II. According to Professor Shlomo Avineri, there are four main reasons for this: the exclusion of large segments of the population from the political elite; the great economic crisis of 2008; the influence of social media; and the after-effects of large-scale waves of immigration. These have created a social class that feels endangered and therefore rejects the existing liberal democratic order. The isolationist, anti-globalization tendency opened a door to forces competing with the West in the international system. The first is Russia, whose military intervention in Ukraine and later in Syria has restored some of the international prestige it had lost when the Cold War ended. The other is China, which is extending its influence over vast regions—including the Middle East and Africa—through its economic policy.

The new Trump administration provides Israel with an opportunity to ensure the stability and strength of its strategic relations with the United States, its most important and loyal ally, as well as continued American support for Israel in every field, especially security. When the presidential election results were announced, the cheers in Jerusalem indicated hope for the start of a new era. But it is imperative that Israel’s leadership does not rush to identify with everything that Trump represents. Trump’s worldview, as presented during the election campaign, encompasses some highly problematic aspects in terms of universal values that Israel must not identify with or adopt, because doing so might come back to haunt Israel in the future. The more that Israel identifies with Trump’s policies, the more it is liable to become the weakest link, targeted by members of the international community who are opposed to Trump and his directives. Furthermore, a blatant cold shoulder to the American Jewish community, the majority who supports the Democratic Party, is short-sighted and can harm Israel in the long-run. Israel must return to being a bipartisan issue, receiving support from both sides of the political aisle.

The Need to Focus on Healing the Rifts
Given the diminishing external threats, Israel’s internal challenges now dominate the public agenda, with the relations between the military and society being a prominent issue. This is not a new phenomenon, however; since its inception, the IDF—being “the people’s army”—and its relations with the people have always been part of the public discourse. But it seems as if in the past year, the tune has changed. In addition to incidents that highlighted the relationship between religion and the military, the most impactful, talked-about event was Elor Azaria’s shooting of the disarmed terrorist in Hebron. The fundamental issue was the hotly debated question of the IDF’s morality and its fighting norms, but the incident also exposed essential differences of opinion on the army’s conduct, the representative institutions of democracy, and the public’s trust in the system. The irresponsible conduct of some officials, motivated by political considerations, severely damaged the status of the state’s judiciary and the public’s trust in the IDF. In this case, the public was subjected to manipulation of the meaning and the boundaries of “security,” which is open to many interpretations, but was used here for political ends that undermine the democratic foundations of the state.
Another issue in the internal arena is the position of the Arab public within the state. Politicians, both Arab and Jewish, have deepened the Jewish-Arab rift and have harmed the relations formed since the creation of the state. Civil society representatives from the Arab sector have asked to end the practice of testing their loyalty; they wholeheartedly identify as Israeli citizens and ask for equality of rights and opportunities. President Reuven (Ruvi) Rivlin’s statement at the conference that the government should make regularizing construction in Israel’s Bedouin settlements and Arab cities its top priority resonated especially with this issue.

The Time to Present a Plan on the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict

As was made clear by all the speakers, as well as by a comprehensive survey the INSS carried out in preparation for the conference, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict lies at the core of Israel’s challenges at every level. The political stalemate and occasional outbursts of violence since October 2015 have led to despair on both sides, and neither has a plan of action that inspires hope for relations between the two peoples in the future. Trump’s inauguration was encouraging because of statements he made both before and after moving into the White House. His unconditional support for Israel creates a new situation in which there is no longer any “bad cop” in Washington who will curb Israeli policy. In such a state of affairs, Israel has a golden opportunity to stop being ambiguous and present a clear policy on the conflict, but there is also a risk that Israel might take rash and irreversible steps.

Israeli politicians have firmly grasped this realization and have tried to propose ideas to improve Israel’s situation. Education Minister Naftali Bennett presented his vision of annexing Areas C and instituting Palestinian autonomy in Areas A and B. His colleague, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked, complemented the proposal by presenting practical steps: moving the embassies of the United States and other nations to Jerusalem, annexing Ma’aleh Adumim and the Etzion Bloc, and undertaking massive construction in the West Bank. Neither was a plan; rather they were merely ideas, because no references were made or considerations given to the many security, political, and moral ramifications of closing off the option of reaching arrangements with the Palestinians as well as its effect on Israel’s international standing. From the other side of the Israeli political map, Yitzhak Herzog and Tzipi Livni, the leaders of the Zionist Camp, presented their vision of two states for two peoples. Herzog listed the steps needed: separating from the Palestinians; instituting a ten-year agreement of non-violence in the area between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River during which a dialogue between the two peoples would be launched to create trust and to develop a foundation for cooperation; accelerating Palestinian economic development; and ending support for terrorism and incitement in the Palestinian Authority. At the end of the ten-year period, it would be possible to discuss a permanent status agreement. This vision, too, is only partial, and is not cohesive enough to serve as a practicable plan of action.

A component shared by all the proposals was the need to improve the Palestinian economy. It seems that there is wide agreement on its importance in stabilizing Israeli-Palestinian relations. This is especially true for the Gaza Strip, which requires serious humanitarian assistance and infrastructural improvement. An interesting component is the plan to build a seaport on an artificial offshore island, as proposed by Transportation and Intelligence Minister Israel Katz. Even greater consensus exists about the opportunity for cooperation with the so-called pragmatic Sunni Arab states. The call to expand cooperation with them already has become commonplace, even trite, and is based on a combination of two basic assumptions: first, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which in the past topped the agenda of many states, has become less important than it was previously and no longer hinders official relations; and second, Israel and the Arab states have many shared interests, from stopping Iran’s influence in the Middle East and defeating ISIS, to issues relating to the economy, infrastructure, and resources. Minister Katz even presented the plan “Trains to the East” as a commercial transportation platform to promote such an agenda. There is nothing wrong with trying to forge closer relations with the Arab states, and Israel’s security relations with Egypt and Jordan have only strengthened the recognition of the positive potential of peace treaties. But Israel’s assumption that there is readiness for establishing open official relations in the absence of progress on the Palestinian political process is not factually grounded and ignores public opinion in the Arab states where the mention of Israel is still a red flag.

In the broader sense, Israel is now experiencing an international intifada, as US General (ret.) David Petraeus put it. A wide range of players are operating against Israel, with only a minority that is anti-Semitic and denies the legitimacy of Israel’s very existence (especially under the banner of the BDS movement), with the majority whose opposition is motivated by Israel’s policy on the Palestinians. UN Security Council Resolution 2334 of December 2016 is an illustrative example. In the eyes of the world, the policy on construction in the West Bank Jewish settlements is a test of Israel’s real intentions: does it want a political resolution based on the two-state solution or not? At the end of the day, Israel’s unwillingness to end its rule over another people in the West Bank and its steps jettisoning the two-state solution, for all intents and purposes, are liable to result in Israel’s political isolation and in danger of being subjected to boycotts and sanctions. The establishment and operation of systems to fight delegitimization can help Israel’s standing here and there, but cannot make a substantial difference. Being willing to make progress in measures that aim for arrangements with the Palestinians, including real steps on the ground, is the best thing Israel can do for itself.

The Question of the Validity of the Non-Intervention Strategy in Syria
Since the beginning of the civil war and the direct involvement of proxies and foreign powers in Syria, Israel has opted for a strategy of non-intervention, unless there is an imminent threat to Israel. Russia’s military intervention, which has become a key factor in shaping Syria’s future, and the growing strength of the pro-Assad coalition—led by Russia and joined by Iran, Hezbollah, and thousands of other Shiite militia fighters—have gained momentum since the victory in Aleppo, with the scales tilted in favor of Assad in the overall balance of power. Eventually, the battles will spread to southern Syria and the Syrian Golan Heights, which is liable to affect Israel directly and increase the chances of escalation vis-à-vis Iran and its proxies—especially Hezbollah—including the Lebanese arena. This analysis indicates that in preparation for such an eventuality, Israel must work more closely with Jordan to establish a joint area of influence in southern Syria and to continue shaping a reality convenient for Israel along the Syrian border by providing civilian and humanitarian assistance to the local communities on the condition that they prevent terrorist activity from their territory.

In Syria, too, much depends on Trump’s policy. Based on what we currently know, it seems he will prefer to focus on defeating ISIS, as his predecessor did, and leave the overall solution to Russia. The shift in the balance between the two major international powers in the Middle East and in general was evident at the Astana Conference, which was led by the Russians and was the first time since World War II that the United States was not a central player in an international process to determine a new world order.

From Israel’s point of view, this is very worrisome, which is why Israel must take prompt, intensive action with the United States to ensure that in any future arrangement in Syria, Iran will not be part of the solution, and neither Iran nor Hezbollah will be allowed a presence in Syria in general and in the Golan Heights in particular. The Israeli effort vis-à-vis Iran must be part of the overall policy on the Iranian regional subversion and its ambition to achieve nuclear capabilities. President Trump has declared his desire to reconsider the July 2015 nuclear deal signed with Iran, although it is hard to tell how serious he is. It is unlikely that a unilateral revocation would serve the best interests of the United States and its allies, including Israel. Either way, Israel must build a joint plan with the United States to combat Iran on two levels. The first and more immediate one is preventing Iranian expansion and subversion in the Middle East. The second is intelligence and operational preparation for the time when the limitations of the nuclear agreement will end and Iran will be free to acquire military nuclear capabilities.

Formulating a Security Doctrine to Meet Current and Future Challenges
Israel must formulate a doctrine to confront the range of challenges presented at the conference, and it must articulate its political and security goals for the future. Based on the topics discussed, several positive points can be discerned about Israel’s strength and military superiority. The IDF’s air force has taken a significant qualitative leap by acquiring the Adir planes (F-35) while also developing advanced capabilities in the field of unmanned aerial vehicles and multi-layer aerial defense systems. An Israeli cyber system was constructed, and is at the forefront of Israeli innovation. The field of cyber demonstrates how it is possible to take a vision and an existing civilian infrastructure and turn them into a powerful tool (of both soft and hard power) to serve the country’s national security. Furthermore, the IDF’s current multiyear plan, the Gideon plan, demonstrates that the IDF is adjusting to a changing world and can adapt both to external processes and internal processes within Israeli society. On the other hand, like the IDF strategy document of August 2015, it also highlights the fact that military plans are not enough and that the absence of a political vision and goals is sorely felt. Currently, the security establishment is operating without a long-term strategic or political direction, and must engage in planning processes based on its own definitions so that the military echelon will be well prepared for the challenges of the future.

 It’s Time to Make Decisions
As 2017 gets under way, Israel is facing more questions than answers. Some are rooted in the uncertainty relating to the new US administration and the implications of that change for Israel’s strategic environment, but many are linked to the Israeli penchant for avoiding decisions that it must make for itself. In the internal arena, the rifts among the various social segments must be healed, and the status of the IDF and the court system must be restored in the name of democracy and ethical principles. In the regional arena, it is possible and desirable to continue to promote cooperation with actors with whom Israel can work, based on overlapping interests—including local forces and influential groups that are not necessarily states—in a graduated, bottom-up manner. In the international arena, it is important to rebuild Israel’s status by relying not only on the Trump administration, but also by accentuating Israel’s added value to the free world when it comes to shared values, the economy, and scientific and technological innovation. Above all, Israel must act decisively to preserve the options for advancing arrangements with the Palestinians, based on separation, with an aim for ending the rule over the Palestinian people in a way that will ensure Israel’s continued existence as a Jewish, democratic, ethical, and secure state, for the good of both peoples.

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Pax Americana is Dead. Long Live . Militias and God unto themselves Muslim El Duces in their own Backyard Domain


The post-American Middle East being born in Syria is an irretrievably changed land of sectarianism and new foreign hegemony


In mid-March 2016 the world marked five years since the outbreak of the civil war in Syria. The number of those killed in the fighting approached half a million. About 10 million Syrians, amounting to about half the population of the state, had lost their homes, and about 8 million had become refugees, fleeing abroad to neighboring Arab states, Turkey, and Europe. About three-quarters of Syria’s social and economic infrastructures—including the health, education, transportation, electricity, and water systems, oil and gas fields, and grain storage facilities—had been ruined or destroyed during the war.

Thus, nothing remains of the Syria over which Bashar al-Assad and his opponents began fighting. In the shadow of the ongoing bloodbath the Syrian state disintegrated into a series of semi-state entities: In eastern Syria and western Iraq the ISIS State (the Islamic Caliphate of Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi) emerged; in the west, in the remains of the original Syrian state, a kind of “Syria Minor,” the Assad dynasty remained and remains in control, enjoying Russian patronage and Iranian influence; in the east and north of the Syrian region there are autonomous Kurdish enclaves; and finally, stretching over large parts of northern Syria and in the south, there are enclaves controlled by various rebel groups—headed by the “Support Front for the People of the Syrian lands” (Al-Nusra Front, or Jabhat al-Nusra), an al-Qaida affiliate.

The fact that the civil war in Syria continues to rage and inflict an ever greater human tragedy on the country’s inhabitants is clear evidence of the impotence of the international community. It has not found the strength or the means to bring the bloody conflict to an end. It has shown even less capacity in the matter of punishing those responsible for the crimes committed during the fighting. For example, the international community failed to take action in response to the Syrian regime’s use of chemical weapons against its own people.

Nevertheless, in Syria and outside of it, indeed, all over the Middle East, during the five years of fighting hopeful eyes continued to be turned mainly to the United States, leader of the “free world” and defender of its values. After all, during the preceding decades it had been customary to consider the United States the “regional policeman,” whose job it was to ensure the region’s stability and protect human rights. But the United States did not come to the aid of Syria and the Syrian people. Rather, outside intervention came from Moscow, which took sides, not so surprisingly, with the Syrian dictator, Assad, whom many view as the main cause of the country’s tragedy. While Russia’s intrusion may lead to the intensification and spread of the violence, it also put Russia on the path to becoming the region’s new policeman, or perhaps its godfather. Furthermore, the situation makes manifest the end of American hegemony in the region, the so-called Pax Americana that endured for nearly a quarter of a century.

***

The Arab Spring that broke out in mid-winter 2010 aroused great hopes in Washington and other Western capitals for a better future for the region’s inhabitants. It turned out, however, to herald something much different. Not only did it turn into a blazing “Islamic Summer,” thanks to the emergence of ISIS, and not only did it wreak havoc on the whole region, but it also brought the era of American influence in the region to an inglorious and bloody end.

The era of Pax Americana has now been replaced by an era of renewed Cold War, even if in a modern version, a war in which Russia competes—with no competitors—for status and influence in the Middle East. Russia is acting on its own, but at the same time it is prepared to cooperate with local godfathers—like Iran and Hezbollah—all of them enemies of the United States and its friends in the region.

In 2009 President Barack Obama won the Nobel Peace Prize. Announcing the prize, the Norwegian Nobel Committee declared: “Only very rarely has a person to the same extent as Obama captured the world’s attention and given its people hope for a better future.” However, ironically, it turned out that during the Obama Administration more people have been killed in the Middle East and around the world than during the administrations of his predecessor, George W. Bush, who became the object of international obloquy for the wars he conducted in Afghanistan and Iraq. The number of terrorist attacks and the number of victims from them has also increased dramatically under Obama. This would seem to indicate that when the United States gets involved and uses its power in the world, the world becomes a more secure and stable place than it does when the United States retreats, disengages, or chooses to “lead from behind,” as it did in the spring 2011 Libyan affair.

Willy-nilly, Syria’s fate affects all the inhabitants of the region. This is due to the country’s historical and geographical centrality, which distinguish it from the other states that have recently experienced similar destructive and ruinous processes, like Libya and Yemen, or even Iraq and Somalia before them. All these states are located on the margins of the Arab world, and, unlike Syria, they never played any formative and central role in its historical and cultural development. What takes place in Syria can be seen as a kind of reflection of what is happening throughout the whole Middle East or a preview of what is likely to happen there in time. In this connection the following trends should be emphasized.

The first trend is the collapse of the Arab territorial nation states, for which Syria serves as an example and model. The Arab states that have collapsed have done so in the face of social and economic difficulties that their mostly dictatorial and corrupt ruling regimes were incapable of handling. The various states’ generally shaky and fragile national identities, whether Syrian, Iraqi, Lebanese, or Palestinian, as well as pan-Arab and territorial identities have been overwhelmed by ethnic, family, tribal, local regional, and, above all, Islamic identities. In many cases Islamic identity became the unifying glue and common ground, as proven by the Syrian case. There, groups of Islamic fighters, like the Support Front or ISIS, have managed to survive the war, while organizations working in the name of Syrian patriotism, like the Free Syrian Army, have collapsed and faded away.

The second trend is the collapse, as a direct result of the disintegration of the Arab states, of the regional system, in whose shadow the political and the social order in the region had lasted for the preceding one hundred years. The regional system based upon the Sykes-Picot agreements—which gave life, authority, and legitimacy to a number of Arab territorial states, most of which lacked historical roots and even legitimacy in the eyes of their inhabitants—has collapsed in the face of the disintegration of many of the states created, such as Libya, Iraq, and Syria. The collapse finds especially clear expression in the case of Syria, which is increasingly falling apart into its basic components. Thus, there is nothing surprising in the fact that ever since ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi proclaimed the establishment of the Islamic Caliphate of ISIS over the territories encompassed by Syria and Iraq, he has boasted that the establishment of this Caliphate amounts to tearing the Sykes-Picot agreements to shreds.

The third trend is that in many cases the collapse of the Arab states has led to the emergence of non-state actors, mostly terrorist organizations or violent groups having a tribal, communal, or Islamic religious identity. Examples of this are ISIS and the Support Front active in Syria and the groups of fighters operating in Libya and Somalia, as well as Hezbollah and Hamas that came on the scene even before them. In addition to the factors just named, the political vacuum that developed in the region served as an invitation to regional and international godfathers, like Iran, Turkey, and, of course, Russia, to enter the field. It is quite likely that Russia and Iran will gain dominance as they sample the muddy waters of the morass the new Middle East has become. Ironically perhaps, the determination and ability of these outsider states to use force without restraint or red lines gives some promise of enduring stability, at least in those areas of interest to them—even as it has dark implications for other areas around the world.

In the face of this gloomy situation, the absence of the United States is more conspicuous than ever. It is absent both as a major player guaranteeing regional stability and as an ally ready to help its partners and friends in the region, as the Obama Administration leans toward appeasing and reaching an agreement with the neighborhood bullies rather than confronting them and attempting to put them in their place.

The major Arab countries remaining intact are Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. In the absence of the United States they have been compelled to face various adversities and challenges at home and abroad on their own, and only with great difficulty have they been able to preserve their cohesiveness and meet the economic needs of their growing populations. Because these states now have very little confidence in Washington’s readiness to assist and protect them in times of crisis, they have become more inclined to resort to force. For example, Saudi Arabia, contrary to its custom in the past, has used force directly in Yemen, and indirectly in Syria as well, mainly because it no longer trusts its American backer.

Under the circumstances, one can expect the use of force and violence to become commonplace in the region—and since, so it seems, the use of chemical weapons in the war in Syria is no longer considered taboo, one can expect greater and greater use of non-conventional weapons. It goes without saying that the effort to acquire nuclear weapons, or at least nuclear capability, will also continue to expand from Iran to other players in the region.

The obvious result of all this is that the Middle East will become a permanently unstable region, subject to frequent convulsions and pervaded with violence and terrorism. It will become a hothouse for radical Islamic ideas and groups that will attract support among the population both within and outside the region.

The shock waves from the crisis in the Middle East have not stopped at the region’s geographical boundaries. Waves of refugees, which will only increase, are knocking on Europe’s gates, while radical Islamic ideology is seeping deeply into Muslim communities all over the world, especially in Europe, and even in the United States. As state frameworks disintegrated and chaos came to prevail in the region, the tide of migration found encouragement and rose sharply, and there is no basis for assuming that it will not continue to rise in the future.

Ironically, America’s withdrawal from playing a role in the Middle East did not save it from being criticized, both within and outside the region, as the main culprit responsible for the present crisis. This stems from the fact that the United States is perceived as the clearest manifestation of the West, and the West is perceived as being guilty of the original sins of imperialism and colonialism, and is therefore seen as the source of the region’s ills. It can be assumed that as the distress and crisis in the region intensify, the resentment of the West and the United States will increase. This being so, the United States is destined to discover what Israel discovered in Lebanon and Gaza: that it is possible to disengage from the Middle East, but the Middle East will not disengage from you.